Follow us on Twitter! Struggling For Air?

Struggling For Air?

by PeteKane 11/1/2009 11:54:00 AM

The auto industry is back at it. In the wake of near collapse, manufacturers are on the attack and on multiple fronts. Americans are shifting (slowly) away from an auto-scentric view to a more multimodal paradigm. Did anyone get to go to Rail~Volution this weekend at the Westin (some really great information and a lot of energy)? But the car companies won't give up without a fight.

Exhibit A
Advertising - Audi recently put out a new ad to promote their "clean diesel" A3 TDI. As they put it, it's more "fun" to do your part by driving their car rather than using any alternative to the automobile. It's quite funny how they show the negative aspects to alternative travel methods and not a single negative aspect to driving a car.

Exhibit B
Design Competition - Lexus is sponsoring the Parkitecture Design Competition. As Americans decide to use other transit options, the need for multiple cars within their family is shrinking. Lexus thinks otherwise. The competition promotes the concept of 1) a free-standing building (great use of land area) and 2) the need to store up to three autos (though they do not state this is for the hypothetical family but they also do not state that you should consider in the design the access by multiple families).

With big budgets and already-established mechanisms, the auto industry has the potential of slowing and/or steering the multimodal paradigm shift that has been brewing. How can we sustain and continue this shift, given this bear's desire to monopolize?

Currently rated 5.0 by 1 people

  • Currently 5/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Tags:

Related posts

Comments

11/3/2009 12:02:56 AM

peter

Pete-great points but I do have to give an ounce of credit to Audi for their diesel car...it is better than nothing. Clean diesels really do have great fuel economy, on par with hybrids. The paradigm shift to more efficient types of transportation will be very incremental and during the transition, more fuel efficient autos are necessary since there will always be populations under-served by public transportation.

peter us

11/3/2009 9:48:38 AM

Disciplining Children

Hi Pete, I agree with peter - i believe that at this time we need more fuel efficient autos - I know i can't handle my transportation needs with the public transportation...

Disciplining Children us

11/3/2009 4:14:54 PM

Alex Reisman

...I think that Audi ad was pretty much made for my dad. It also reminds me of an Onion headline I love: "95% of Americans Favor Public Transportation for Others" or something like that. I think there is growing receptiveness to alternative modes of travel, and I agree that we need to think about how to cultivate that further. Nonetheless, I'm hard pressed to imagine that, like the automakers, the auto enthusiasts in my life (dad, sister, boss, friend) would give up the car thing anytime soon. It's a part of the future too.

Pete, I like your idea about a garage with multifamily access, especially if you intend for that in a single-family home setting. Even though you're feeling cynical about the contest, maybe you should submit something like that - I bet Dwell would eat it up.

Alex Reisman us

11/3/2009 7:14:05 PM

mark

Regarding that Onion headline, though funny, the consequence is real and to me tragic. Its kind of like the thought that the worse thing is when good men see bad things happen and do nothing to make a difference.

mark us

11/4/2009 1:25:03 PM

PeteKane

The main issue I see with the Audi ad is not so much their efforts for a more environmentally-friendly car (that's awesome), but their positioning. When a person (or company in this example) resorts to attacks, you've lost the battle. If Audi were to promote the cleanliness of their car compared to their previous models, they will gain more respect. To however initiate the discussion by demeaning alternative transportation methods as pedestrian and problem-ridden, that's where it falls apart.

Alex - great suggestion about submitting the alternate garage concept.

PeteKane us

11/4/2009 3:02:41 PM

PeteKane

One other interesting element regarding the Audi ad was the setting used. The alternative transportation methods were all located in urban areas. Audi then contrasted this with driving their clean diesel car - out in the country/hillside. A fairer comparison (potentially) would be to show how "fun" it is to drive that Audi in the same urban setting as the alt-methods. Generally speaking, city driving is why people choose alternative modes (downtown Boston anyone?).

PeteKane us

11/5/2009 1:33:49 PM

Darrell

Its really a systemic problem that all parties should take some blame for. Oh sure the auto industry has been slow to respond, but lets look at what consumers in North America have been demanding. We as a society have to stand up and say "NO" we won't buy your gas gozzling auto's anymore. We demand clean and efficient running vehicles that won't pollute our environment. We all have to take some responsibility as well in our daily lives and how we live. Not just what kind of vehicles we drive.

Darrell us

11/7/2009 8:48:12 PM

emails

Regarding that Onion headline, though funny, the consequence is real and to me tragic. Its kind of like the thought that the worse thing is when good men see bad things happen and do nothing to make a difference..

emails gb

Add comment


(Will show your Gravatar icon)  

  Country flag





Live preview

11/22/2009 1:07:56 AM

Powered by Web Cosmo

Search


Calendar

<<  November 2009  >>
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
2627282930311
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30123456

View posts in large calendar

Recent comments

© Copyright 2009
Sign in