Follow us on Twitter! MTA Proposal Singles Out East Boston

MTA Proposal Singles Out East Boston

by RianAmiton 11/20/2008 12:16:00 PM

There's a firestorm brewing surrounding the Mass Turnpike Authority's latest revenue-generating proposal.

The MTA wants to significantly increase tolls in the tunnels that connect East Boston to the rest of the city.  Understandably, this has set many Eastie residents, business owners, property owners and representatives into a panic.

MA House Speaker Sal DeMasi has offered an alternative proposal: Hike the state-wide gas tax instead.

I can understand the potential argument that it would be unfair to tax all MA drivers to cover MTA's debt.  But would it be fair for the MTA to single out a neighborhood that's on realatively unsteady economic footing as it is?  (Here's the 2000 Census data for East Boston).

For the record, this very unscientific poll finds overwhelming support for raising the gas tax instead of the tunnel tolls.

Be the first to rate this post

  • Currently 0/5 Stars.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Tags: , , ,

Related posts

Comments

11/24/2008 11:35:14 PM

Eric Senecal

Great post Rian. It's like we've got a regular column to read.

I've been thinking about the Turnpike Authority's toll hike a lot. There were back to back front page Boston Globe articles last week that somehow didn't get linked by any of the editorials and letters that followed. The first was a good piece about the Big Dig and congestion in metro Boston. I was glad to see that it followed up some quotes about how commutes have become longer for some with a brief mention of the new trips that the improvements to the downtown bottleneck have generated. I wish the author had developed this aspect of the story a little more.

The next day the toll hike vote was front and center. Noticeably absent from any of the story or subsequent discussion was the lack of tolling for i-93, either north or south of the city. We all know (well, anyone who has commuted on I-93) that here lies the worst of the congestion. I am amazed that so little talk of tolling this road has surfaced from this thorny debate. Unlike the direct link that the harbor tunnels have to East Boston, I-93 captures much more of the regional traffic that is responsible for tying up the commute at peak hours.

I wonder if it is just not politically feasible to ask drivers to pay a fee to use a road that has laid a $15 billion dollar burden on the state. I wrote a letter to the globe and the authors, curious about details of this free highway. I think depressing the central artery was a good plan. But if it's going to continue to be free to access, I don't think any of these problems, congestion, revenue generation, or equitable access will go away.

I agree that it might not be fair to raise gas taxes on everyone when the problem is clearly that we need to pay for the Big Dig. It also seems very regressive to isolate East Boston. But what about tolling the road that has so benefited from the Big Dig and which carries by far the most vehicles on a daily basis. Perhaps if this were added to the mix, the impact could be eased on East Boston.

Eric Senecal us

11/28/2008 5:57:18 PM

RianAmiton

Good points, Eric. It is odd that tolling I-93 instead -- or just as much -- as the harbor tunnels hasn't been offered as a legit alternative, isn't it?

I thought the first Globe article you referenced was kind of weird. The gist of it seemed to be: the Big Dig hasn't alleviated ALL of the Boston area's traffic woes. Well, no sh*t -- nobody ever promised it would, did they? But yeah, it was nice to see the mention (however briefly) of the if-you-build-it-they-will-just-drive-more phenomenon.

RianAmiton us

9/16/2009 3:15:14 AM

Club Penguin Cheats

It's an interesting proposal. I think residents of MA who live outside of Boston would object to a raise in the statewide gas tax to fund some tunnels they're unlikely to ever use. But I can understand how a huge hike in the tunnel fees seems unfair to local residents who have few alternate options to get around town. BTW, I love the depth of field effect on the photo for this article. It makes the street scene look like a little miniature model. Cool!

Club Penguin Cheats us

Add comment


(Will show your Gravatar icon)  

  Country flag





Live preview

11/21/2009 9:05:07 PM

Powered by Web Cosmo

Search


Calendar

<<  November 2009  >>
MoTuWeThFrSaSu
2627282930311
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30123456

View posts in large calendar

Recent comments

© Copyright 2009
Sign in